LOF-P-015: Alignment with existing legal standards¶
Proposed for adoption
This principle is part of a proposal for adoption, Adopt principles: scope and coordination (#57), which is not yet open for decision. Comments are welcome now, from anyone. When it opens, members will be able to approve or object here.
Draft for ratification
Part of the founding draft of the LOF principles.
Summary¶
The ontology documents its relationship to established legal information standards.
Purpose¶
Legal information already circulates in established formats. Documented mappings let Foundry ontologies annotate that data rather than compete with it.
Recommendations and requirements¶
- Where a relevant standard exists (for example Akoma Ntoso, LegalRuleML, LKIF, ELI, ECLI), the README states whether and how the ontology maps to it.
- Term-level mappings, where provided, use
skos:exactMatch,skos:closeMatch,skos:broadMatch, orskos:narrowMatch, or a SSSOM mapping file. - Mappings are not asserted as logical equivalences unless the ontological commitments have been checked.
Implementation¶
Keep mappings in a separate SSSOM file under src/mappings/ when they are numerous.
Examples¶
A class for judgments mapped to the Akoma Ntoso judgment document type with skos:closeMatch.
Criteria for review¶
Relevant standards are identified, and mappings use the appropriate SKOS strength.
Automated check: None. Manual review.
Feedback and discussion¶
Propose changes to this principle by pull request against
docs/principles/lof-p-015-standards.md, or open a thread in
Discussions.