Skip to content

LOF-P-010: Jurisdictional transparency

Proposed for adoption

This principle is part of a proposal for adoption, Adopt principles: legal specificity (#58), which is not yet open for decision. Comments are welcome now, from anyone. When it opens, members will be able to approve or object here.

comment without GitHub ยท comment on GitHub

Draft for ratification

Part of the founding draft of the LOF principles.

Summary

Classes specific to a legal system or jurisdiction carry a dcterms:coverage annotation naming it, and are not presented as universal.

Purpose

Legal categories vary across systems. A class that silently generalizes from one jurisdiction ("consideration" in common-law contract, say) misrepresents others and produces false inferences when data from several systems is combined.

Recommendations and requirements

  1. The registry entry lists the jurisdictions or legal traditions in scope (jurisdictions), or general if the ontology claims generality.
  2. Classes restricted to particular jurisdictions carry a dcterms:coverage annotation naming them.
  3. Claims of cross-jurisdictional generality are supported by documentation.

Implementation

Mark each such class with one dcterms:coverage annotation per jurisdiction or tradition, using these values:

Scope Value Example
A country ISO 3166-1 alpha-2 code "BR" (Brazil)
A subdivision (state, province) ISO 3166-2 code "US-TX" (Texas)
The European Union "EU" "EU"
A legal tradition one of common-law, civil-law, religious-law, customary-law, international-law "common-law"

A class with no dcterms:coverage annotation is presented as general, so the annotation is required, not optional, for every class whose definition depends on a particular legal system.

Examples

A class consideration annotated with dcterms:coverage "common-law".

Criteria for review

Jurisdiction-specific classes are annotated. The ontology's generality claims are plausible given its sources.

Automated check: none yet; a check of dcterms:coverage values against the table above is planned. Whether a class needs the annotation remains a matter for manual review.

Feedback and discussion

Propose changes to this principle by pull request against docs/principles/lof-p-010-jurisdiction.md, or open a thread in Discussions.

Discussion