Skip to content

LOF-ODP-006: Relations between Norms

Particularization, derogation, conflict between the positions legal content grounds, and determinations of which content prevails, on what ground, and according to whom, distinguishing determinations with legal force from readings without it.

ID odp-006
Prefix ODP006
Term IRI pattern https://w3id.org/lof/ODP006_nnnnnnn
Domain legal ontology design pattern
Jurisdictions general
Status draft (active)
Repository https://github.com/legal-ontologies-foundry/lof-odp-006
Issue tracker https://github.com/legal-ontologies-foundry/lof-odp-006/issues
License CC BY 4.0
Contact David R. Koepsell (drkoepsell@tamu.edu)

Products

Product IRI
Full release https://w3id.org/lof/odp-006.owl
Base release https://w3id.org/lof/odp-006/odp-006-base.owl

Dependencies

Description

Relates items of legal content by particularization and derogation (substitutive or blocking), locates conflict between the legal positions they ground and lifts it to the content, and records precedence determinations (lex superior, specialis, posterior, primacy of an overriding legal order) with their source; only determinations that are themselves legal content make one content prevail over another. SHACL shapes report unresolved, contested, and unauthoritatively resolved conflicts. The full specification is on the pattern page.

Discussion