Skip to content

Normative Accountability Ontology (NAO)

Being held to account. Norms and their breaches, the residue a breach leaves, the capacities that make an agent answerable, the responses by which breaches are answered, and the displacement of answerability from resettable artifacts to those who deploy them.

ID nao
Prefix NAO
Term IRI pattern https://w3id.org/lof/NAO_nnnnnnn
Domain normative accountability (legal, moral, professional, and institutional norms)
Jurisdictions general
Status draft (active)
Repository https://github.com/legal-ontologies-foundry/lof-nao
Issue tracker https://github.com/legal-ontologies-foundry/lof-nao/issues
License CC BY 4.0
Contact David R. Koepsell (drkoepsell@tamu.edu)

Products

Product IRI
Full release https://w3id.org/lof/nao.owl
Base release https://w3id.org/lof/nao/nao-base.owl

Dependencies

Usages

  • Worked example: three scenarios from the classroom demonstration The Reset Button (a physician, a resettable diagnostic system, a permanent AI, and an autonomous probe), with a plain-language accountability report

Publications

  • The Irreversible Accountability Test ()

Description

A BFO 2020 ontology of being held to account, published in two modules. NAO core (23 classes, 12 relations, five patterns) commits to nothing beyond BFO and the LOF design patterns, and can be used by anyone modeling accountability. NAO-IAT adds the Irreversible Accountability Test as two exclusion axioms, so that the thesis can be adopted, tested, or left aside separately from the vocabulary.

NAO links to the legal patterns through codified as (a moral answerability codified as an LOF-ODP-003 legal position) and LOF-ODP-004 (a breach that triggers that position is inferred to be a triggering occurrence). The scope discussion is in the new ontology request issue.

Discussion